F.A.Q.

Everything we get asked, in one place. Can't find your answer? Call (888) 565-6150 or email info@icingonthering.com — a real person will get back to you.

Visiting Us

DO I NEED AN APPOINTMENT?

Saturdays are appointment-based — booking ahead guarantees you dedicated one-on-one time, and walk-ins are welcome when space allows. Monday through Friday, come by anytime; appointments are recommended for engagement ring consultations so we can give you our full attention.

WHERE DO I PARK?

Park at the Pershing Square garage, just steps away — we validate parking with purchase. Street parking is also available nearby.

HOW LONG DOES A VISIT TAKE?

Plan for about 45 minutes to an hour for a full consultation. Just browsing? Come by anytime — stay as long as you like.

I DON'T KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT DIAMONDS. IS THAT OK?

That's exactly what we're here for. Most of our clients are buying an engagement ring for the first time — we'll explain everything in plain language and help you compare options side by side.

CAN I SEE TACORI IN PERSON?

Yes — we're the exclusive Tacori Platinum retailer in the LA Jewelry District, with their collections in our showroom to try on.

CAN I REQUEST A SPECIFIC ADVISOR?

Yes! Just add their name to your notes when booking online, and we'll confirm their availability.

WHAT SHOULD I INCLUDE IN MY APPOINTMENT REQUEST?

So we can prepare for your visit, include anything specific you'd like to cover and the budget range you're comfortable with. That way we can have the right selection ready and waiting when you arrive.

Ordering, Payment & Financing

HOW LONG DOES IT TAKE TO MAKE A RING?

Most made-to-order and custom pieces take up to 14 business days — about three weeks — depending on the design. We'll give you a timeline when you order and keep you updated throughout.

DOES ICING ON THE RING OFFER FINANCING?

Yes — we offer financing through Affirm as well as an in-house layaway plan, available both in-store and online. Ask us about current offers and we'll help you find the option that fits.

Shipping & Delivery

IS SHIPPING INSURED?

Yes. Every order ships fully insured and tracked, with a signature required on delivery. Insurance covers your item while it's in transit; once it's delivered and signed for, it's in your hands.

IS A SIGNATURE REQUIRED FOR DELIVERY?

Yes, on every home or office delivery. By default, though, we ship to a UPS Access Point near you, where your package is held securely until you pick it up — no doorstep, no worry.

CAN I PICK UP MY ORDER IN-STORE INSTEAD OF SHIPPING IT?

Absolutely. Choose in-store pickup and collect your order at our showroom at 607 S Hill St #316 in the LA Jewelry District.

Returns & Exchanges

HOW LONG DO I HAVE TO RETURN OR EXCHANGE MY ORDER?

14 calendar days from the day your order is delivered or picked up in-store. After 14 days, returns and exchanges are no longer accepted.

WHAT ITEMS ARE ELIGIBLE FOR RETURN OR EXCHANGE?

In-stock items purchased online or in our showroom, returned in brand-new condition — unworn, undamaged, and unaltered — with all original packaging and documentation, including the diamond certificate if your piece came with one.

ARE CUSTOM OR MADE-TO-ORDER PIECES RETURNABLE?

No. Custom pieces, special orders, engraved items, and anything resized or altered are final sale. If something about your custom piece doesn't feel right, reach out — we'll talk it through with you.

DO I PAY FOR RETURN SHIPPING?

Yes — for shipped returns, you arrange and pay for insured return shipping. We'll walk you through how to pack and insure your item properly. In-store returns are always free — just bring your item in.

MY RING DOESN'T FIT — WHAT DO I DO?

In most cases you don't need a return — resizing is free within your first year. See Lifetime Warranty & Privileges for details.

Warranty & Care

WHAT DOES THE WARRANTY NOT COVER?

Daily wear and tear, damage from accidents, loss, theft, or unauthorized alterations are not covered under the warranty. Think of the warranty as our promise to stand behind our craftsmanship, while general care remains in your hands.

DO YOU OFFER COMPLIMENTARY CLEANING AND INSPECTIONS?

Yes! We encourage you to bring your jewelry in for free cleaning and inspection at least once a year to help maintain its brilliance and integrity.

WHAT HAPPENS IF A DIAMOND FALLS OUT OF MY RING?

If the diamond was lost due to a manufacturing defect, we'll replace it at no cost. For damage caused by wear and tear, we can repair it for a fee — always quoted before any work begins.

DO I NEED TO DO ANYTHING TO KEEP MY WARRANTY VALID?

Nothing — your warranty isn't conditional on inspections or maintenance visits. We encourage a free annual cleaning and inspection to keep your jewelry at its best, but skipping it never affects your coverage. The one thing that can void your warranty is repair or alteration work performed by another jeweler.

CAN I TAKE MY JEWELRY TO ANOTHER JEWELER FOR MAINTENANCE?

To keep your warranty valid, repairs or adjustments should only be performed by Icing On The Ring. Work done elsewhere may void the warranty.

DO I NEED MY RECEIPT TO MAKE A WARRANTY CLAIM?

No. We keep a record of every IOTR purchase — just bring your piece in and we'll take care of the rest.

WHAT ARE THE RESIZING TERMS?

Resizing is free within your first year of purchase, for adjustments within one full size up or down. Eternity bands, tungsten, and carbide can't be resized under this policy. After the first year, or for larger adjustments, we're happy to resize your ring — we'll quote the job before starting.

HOW LONG DO SERVICES TAKE?

Resizing and refurbishing each take up to two weeks. We'll confirm timing when you drop off your piece.

IS MY TACORI OR DESIGNER PIECE COVERED?

Yes — designer pieces are protected by our warranty and the designer's own manufacturer warranty.

Diamond Trade-Up

HOW DOES THE DIAMOND TRADE-UP PROGRAM WORK?

When you're ready to upgrade, bring in your original diamond from Icing On The Ring. We'll apply 100% of what you paid for your diamond toward a new diamond that is at least 50% more in value, and the same type (lab for lab, natural for natural).

DOES THE SETTING COUNT TOWARD THE TRADE-UP?

The program applies to your diamond only. If you'd like, we can help you design a new setting to fit your upgraded stone.

DO I NEED THE ORIGINAL RECEIPT OR PAPERWORK?

No receipt needed — we keep a record of every IOTR purchase. What we do need is the diamond itself in its original undamaged condition, and if it's certified, its original undamaged certificate.

CAN I TRADE UP MORE THAN ONCE?

Yes — there's no limit, and the program lasts a lifetime. Each time you trade up, 100% of what you paid for your current diamond goes toward the new one, and the new diamond just needs to be at least 50% greater in value.

CAN I TRADE A NATURAL DIAMOND FOR A LAB-GROWN ONE, OR VICE VERSA?

Trade-ups stay within the same diamond type — natural to natural, lab-grown to lab-grown.

IS MY TACORI OR DESIGNER DIAMOND ELIGIBLE?

Yes. Keep in mind designer pieces can take a little longer, since the designer completes the setting work on your upgraded stone.